Must Visit Restaurants in the Florida Keys

One of our favorite things to do on vacation is eat! So we have tried quite a few restaurants throughout the Keys in our visits. Here are some of our favorites. We have never had a bad meal in the Keys, so feel confident that wherever you go will be delicious!

Upper Keys

• Islamorada Fish Company (MM81.5)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Great overwater area with seating, live music. Added bonus … It’s attached to Worldwide Sportsman, so you can shop and check out the sister ship to Hemingway’s Pilar.

Middle Keys

• Angler & Ale (MM61)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Located at Hawks Cay Resort on Duck Key. Their Lobster “French” Dip was one of my favorite meals of the trip. It’s an adult lobster grilled cheese with lobster bisque instead of tomato soup. Their desserts are also on point! We would know because we tried almost all of them.
• SS Wreck & Galley Grill (MM59)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • The Mahi BLT is delicious and pairs well with their award winning Key Lime Pie.
• Island Fish Company (MM54)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Save room for the Deep Fried Key Lime Pie! It is my favorite in the Keys (so far). Fun Fact! This is the only restaurant in the Keys that you can reach by air, land or sea. There is a heliport in the parking lot.
• Sparky’s Landing Fish n Cocktails (MM53.5)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Waterfront restaurant with great atmosphere and drinks. We love this place because we can arrive by boat from the house we rent in Key Colony Beach.
• Key Colony Inn (MM53.5 in Key Colony Beach)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Short walk from anywhere in Key Colony Beach. The bar will be full of locals and their expresso martinis are a hit.
• 7 Mile Grill (MM47.5)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Part of the Keys since 1954. Whole in the wall vibe and all day breakfast. What more could you ask for?!?!
• Sunset Grille & Raw Bar (MM47)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Waterfront restaurant at the foot of 7 Mile Bridge. Beautiful sunsets and home of Sunday Funday – the Florida Keys longest running pool & beach party.

Lower Keys

• Hog Fish Bar & Grill (MM4.5)
  • Click Here for Menu
    • This is a favorite that we try to make it to every year. Located on Stock Island, it is a place the locals love, for good reason.
• Cafe Sole
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Fantastic french restaurant in Key West. We celebrated here on an anniversary trip and still rave about our meals.
• Conch Republic Seafood Company
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Kinda like an old faithful. If we are out exploring in Key West and need dessert and a drink, this is our go to.
• Latitudes at Sunset Key
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Sunset Key is a private island off of Key West and home to Sunset Key Cottages. Their restaurant, Latitudes is available to those not staying on Sunset Key. There is a ferry from Key West to Sunset Key.
• Blue Heaven
  • Click Here for Menu
    • A one of a kind Key West experience with chickens and cats roaming the premise. And if meringue is your thing…their Key Lime Pie might just be your favorite!
• Louie’s Backyard
  • Click Here for Menu
    • Oceanfront seating, delicious food in a house that is on the National Register of Historic Places.